New series: Fly-fishing’s leading voices answer our quick-fire questions. This month, David Profumo

Q

Do you believe that some people possess innate abilities that make them better fishers?

Without a doubt — just as certain gardeners have “green fingers”, some anglers just seem to have “hands” and are predisposed to effortless superiority. It is still better to be lucky than good, but I envy those with natural talent.

Q

Can someone be considered a “proper” fly-fisher if they don’t tie their own flies?

I think so: fly-dressing is one of fishing’s beautiful ancillary skills and there’s much potential for experimentation and modification, but it’s simply a bonus — not many golfers make their own balls.

Q

It’s been said that Euro-nymphing isn’t really fly-fishing. Some even believe that it’s detrimental to our sport. Do you use the method?

I rarely practice the Euro (or tight-line) but I acknowledge its expertise and the fact that it can be wildly effective. There is a school of thought that if you’re not actually casting a fly-line then you might as well be trotting bait, but it doesn’t bother me.

Q

What is the first drink you order at the bar after a day on the water?

As a consummate sponger, I usually persuade someone else to get the first round in. Choice of tipple is dependent on climate — in Cuba, a mojito “con cojones” is peerless if constructed with the correct spearmint, whereas in Ireland, as an author, I stick to Writers’ Tears whiskey.

Q

Social media influencers are having a growing impact on fishing. Is that a good thing?

When it comes to social media I am something of a Cro-Magnon man, but I do think influencers are a mixed blessing, and the Internet is something of a poisoned chalice. As a traditionalist I prefer the time-honoured piscatorial system of bankside or taproom word of mouth, received wisdom, old wives’ tales and blether. Who really wants to annihilate mystique with technique?

David and guide Teihotu (Marlon Brando's son) with a hefty Tahitian bonefish.

A lucky escape: David after the chopper crash in Russia.

Q

A fish must be caught to save your life. Who would you choose to catch it, and why?

I have been lucky enough to know many celebrated and skilful fisherfolk (from Falkus and Buller to Mr Crabtree) but I would stake my life on the late Poet Laureate Ted Hughes, an occasional sporting companion of mine, who rarely gave up before he had something on the bank.

Q

What are your thoughts on the competition scene? Some believe that it makes them better fishers, while others argue that it contradicts the very essence of fly-fishing.

My first-hand experience of the competition scene is fairly limited, though back in the ’90s (as Fishing Correspondent of The Telegraph) I did fish practice sessions with both male and female England fly squads, and was awed by their prowess. But it’s not my sort of thing — I fear it reduces angling to the equivalent of skeet shooting. Having said that, I did once win a gudgeon tournament on the River Kennet.

Q

What is your current fishing car?

I’ve tried Jeep, Audi and Mercedes but for the last 26 years I have driven a Land Rover Defender. The most impressive one I ever saw belonged to chef Marco Pierre White, totally rigged out for pike fishing. During one inner-city dawn raid on esox he dished up Pot Noodles for breakfast.

Q

It’s been said that ambivalence towards important causes is our great weakness as fishers. Should we be more vocal in standing up for our sport and the environments that support it?

Yes, yes: the future of sport fishing here in the UK is by no means certain, and the public perception of it — despite sterling efforts by several bodies — remains ambivalent. We are in danger of losing our strong base of family anglers, and the Great Indoors has seriously eroded numbers. We must maintain the tradition of mentoring, and remind the world that when it comes to the aquatic environment it is often anglers who are the eyes and ears, though they seldom get much credit for it. I am wary of certain “right to roam” groups, “activist” canoeing bodies, and indeed the politics of the Green Party.

Giant Trevally, 45lb, Tahiti.

Casting for a catfish in the centre of Florence.

Q

What do you listen to on your way to the water?

Usually I just pay attention to the little goblin voices in my head that whisper about luck, tactics, weather, superstition and friendship. Depending on the time of day, I may listen to Iggy Pop or Creedence Clearwater Revival.

Q

Tell us the strangest, or scariest, experience you’ve had while fly-fishing.

In 1991, I joined an exploratory trip to the recently opened Umba River on Russia’s Kola peninsula. It was July, and we fished for salmon through the cool “white nights” as the daytime was blazing and there were mosquitoes big enough to hump a turkey. Around one in the morning, on the fourth, I was wading just above an isthmus where the river divided into several streams and debouched into a lake, when I heard the singing — high, ethereal female voices on the wind, although in that taiga wilderness there wasn’t another human soul to be seen for miles around. It was entrancing rather than spooky. After a long while, I reeled in and went back upstream a couple of miles to where my pal Simon had been fishing. “So, you heard it too,” he said. That spot had previously for centuries been a seasonal netting place for the semi-nomadic Saami people, and I think their ritual chanting had somehow engrained itself into the stones and the atmosphere. I do believe there are “thin places” where this world of ours is but narrowly separated from other times and spaces. I was also on the Kola on the same date — July 4 — in 2001, when one morning I strapped myself into the co-pilot’s seat of our Mi-2 helicopter which was due to transport our party of seven to the Sidorovka River. Shortly thereafter we were involved in a spectacular and gruesome crash landing (no fatalities, fortunately, but plenty of injuries requiring hospital). So I feel I have seen Mother Russia quite close enough for one lifetime.

Q

Does using high-quality tackle make a difference to your catch returns?

I like to think so, as I am an absolute “tackle tart” (over a hundred rods in my collection, including two excellent Loop models this season alone); but I think the advantages may be largely psychological. As Lefty Kreh once observed, most modern tackle is too good for the majority of casters to exploit to its true potential.

A 25lb Cuban permit.

David with a recent spate river salmon from the Laxford, Scotland.

Q

What is the greatest life lesson that fishing has taught you?

It’s perseverance rather than patience. Cultivate a sense of irony and gallows humour. Choose your companions with care, as the context within which fishing occurs is vitally important. Become a “possibilitarian” (make the most of every opportunity). And remember, as Qui-Gon Jinn noted (in Star Wars Episode 1), “There’s always a bigger fish.”

Q

While catch-and-release is now widespread in the fly-fishing world, some people endeavour to land as many fish as possible. Should more restraint be shown?

I am ethically conflicted about mandatory “catch-and-release”: if you have absolutely no intention of retaining any fish whatsoever to eat, then are you justified in interfering with the lives of these wonderful wild creatures in the first place? I know of course the conservation arguments, but every angler needs to square this with his or her conscience. Personally, I sleep sound at night.

Q

Imagine: an environmental law is proposed that would see every river, lake and ocean on Earth restored to perfect health for eternity. The catch: it can only be passed if you give up fishing. What do you do?

Bad luck on the environment, folks — I would still fish on until my dying day, I’m afraid… 

PHOTOGRAPHY: DAVID PROFUMO/GLYN SATTERLEY

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

David Profumo

David Profumo is an award-winning author and journalist, and a Fellow of the Royal Society of Literature. He has fished in forty-five different countries, and his latest book is The Lightning Thread. Fishological Moments and the Pursuit of Paradise, published in paperback by Scribner UK.

Cookie policy | Privacy policy